




|
SELECTED REVIEWS FOR
NEXT OF KIN
From The Los
Angeles Times Sunday Book Review, Richard Wrangham
... Next of Kin is more than a book about the theory and
practice of science. It's a love story.... Scientists aren't supposed to
have their objectivity ruined by emotional involvement. But Next of Kin
shows that the ape experiments that fail are those that forbid human
sympathy for their subjects. For Fouts, chimpanzee and human minds are
fundamentally alike, so it makes sense to care deeply about one's
chimpanzee subjects.
What Fouts has learned
from chimpanzees is that Descartes was wrong. Other animals do have minds.
The reason chimpanzees are should be greater. That argument isn't new, but
in Next of Kin, it is based on an unparalleled depth of
understanding and on a uniquely personal involvement in the battles over
congressional legislation and laboratory management. You cannot read this
book and stay neutral.
From Audiofile
Roger Fouts recounts the remarkable story of his career teaching
chimpanzees the skill of "signing." Discoveries and insights
into chimpanzee intelligence will amaze the listener as Fouts proudly
reveals their capabilities. Because Fouts began his career as a novice,
his naive enthusiasm for his work was fraught with the jealousy and deceit
of other researchers. Fouts's love and respect for the chimps he
calls"family" superseded all obstacles including
near-bankruptcy. Compassion is intertwined with anger as he describes his
longtime fight to prevent researchers from using these biological
relatives as victims of cruel and inhumane medical and scientific
research. Grief-filled words describe the unnecessary and cruel
psychological destruction and death of some of his closest chimpanzee
brothers and sisters. B.J.P. ©AudioFile, Portland, Maine From
Booklist, August 19, 1997
Can chimpanzees talk? As Fouts explains in this fascinating account,
the answer to this question is no. But if the question is rephrased as,
Can chimpanzees communicate using nonverbal language? the answer is a
resounding yes. In the late 1960s, Washoe, a female chimpanzee, was taught
American Sign Language in a groundbreaking study. Fouts was involved with
Project Washoe from the beginning, and this account of the experiment and
its aftermath reads like a novel. The ups (such as Washoe's inventions of
novel signs or names for things) and downs (working with an unpredictable
and arrogant senior scientist) of the unfolding story are intertwined with
the scientific theories and concepts that underlie all the research being
described. The similarities between humans and chimpanzees, particularly
in their behavior (and language acquisition is the main behavior being
studied), are emphasized and explained in the clear, easy-to-understand
narrative. The evolutionary and genetic bases for these similarities are
explored early in the text and are woven through the descriptions of
Washoe's continuing acquisition of language. By comparing Washoe's
behavior in captivity with both the behavior of wild chimpanzees and with
autistic children, Fouts leads readers through complex scientific concepts
while entertaining them with Washoe's (and his own) stories. What makes
this book an exceptional popularization of scientific research is the
authors' ability to charm with a fascinating story while also teaching why
the story is so fascinating. Extensive notes round out a terrific book
that is recommended for all libraries. Movie and foreign rights sold;
special promotions to animal-rights groups planned. Nancy Bent
Copyright© 1997, American Library Association. All rights reserved From
Kirkus Reviews , August 1, 1997
Though he was studying theories of communication, Fouts
(Psychology/Central Washington Univ.) learned a whole lot more than that
from the chimps in his American Sign Language program, and he tells their
story here with great insight and affection. Thirty years ago, Fouts
started teaching chimps American Sign Language (ASL), in hopes of being
able to speak directly with them. He was under no illusion that he was
teaching chimps the art of communication: They had been communicating in
the wild for millennia, with gestures, the dialects of hand movement,
facial expressions, and body language. Nonetheless, Fouts was astounded by
the speed at which his charges took to ASL and their talents for wordplay
and grammar. His research allowed him to put in perspective theories of
animal intelligence and language acquisition, from Descartes and Darwin to
Skinner and Chomsky, and to formulate his own notions of the remarkable
similarity between chimp and human biology and intelligence, of grammar as
a complex form of rule-following behavior, and how ASL helped him bridge
the sundered audiovisual links experienced by autistics. But clearly the
most important thing Fouts feels he learned is that these creatures don't
belong in cages, and no matter how much compassion and respect are given
the research subjects, morally and ethically, keeping them in captivity is
wrong. To drive that point home, he details the barbaric conditions in
which lab animals are kept, the excruciating tests they are put through,
in powerfully soulful language. And though he can't be counted among the
draconians, Fouts recognizes his own culpability in the diminished lives
of his charges. A compelling book. Fouts (aided by wildlife writer Mills)
has a way of making us all feel responsibility for the fate of these
chimps and for the hellacious acts against them. Jane Goodall has written
the book's introduction. (16 pages b&w photos not seen) (First
printing of 50,000; first serial to Reader's Digest; film rights to Fox
2000; Book-of-the-Month Club featured selection; author tour) -- Copyright
©1997, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved
|